Character and the Presidency

Jonah Goldberg and David Horowitz recently got into a spat over President Bush's character. It began with a tweet from Goldberg: " Re-asking a question I've been posing for three years: Please come up with a definition of good character that Donald Trump can clear. "

Horowitz gave a quick answer which Goldberg rejected then went into detail here.

He also point out that there are two varieties of never-Trumpers. My take on this is that there are the ones who hate Trump so much that they reverse long-held positions just to oppose Trump (Jenifer Rubins and moving the embassy to Jerusalem) and the ones who admit that they share values with Trump but still hate his style. The first group is totally irrational. The second group might be reasoned with.

First, I'd like to hit Goldberg with a counter-question: Please come up with a definition of good character that Hillary could clear but Trump can't. Seriously, in terms of honesty and truthfulness, Hillary sets a very low bar. It's been said that she will never tell a simple truth when she can tell a complicated lie instead. And the allegations of campaign finance violations are nothing to things the Clintons have gotten away with. Fifteen of their friends and associates were convicted in the Whitewater investigation. Further, multiple reports say that Hillary is rude to the Secret Service and other staffers while Trump is warm and friendly.

So anyone saying that he'd prefer Hillary to Trump is really saying that he prefers to be on the outside complaining about the ones in power rather than having to defend policies that he is supposed to support. Or that he needs to learn to say, "I hate Trump's style but I agree with what he's doing."

But how important is character in a president anyway? Yes, Trump cheated on his wives. So did Clinton, JFK, FDR, Jefferson, and possibly others. It's hard to think of any way that Bill Clinton was a better person than Donald Trump. It wasn't widely reported but Clinton was known for his purple-face rages. His press secretary, George Stephanopoulos, said that Clinton yelled at him for up to 45 minutes at the start of every day!

Going back further, name a test for good character that Nixon and LBJ could pass that Trump could not. Both were effective presidents and both used dirty tricks.

Ronald Reagan, the gold standard for Republican presidents, was the first president to be divorced. He was also cold and distant to his children.

Then there's the flip side. Jimmy Carter is considered a very nice man and a failure as a president. George H. W. Bush was known as a gentleman and was a one-term president. Few of the never-Trumpers cared for George W. Bush, either but he is now being held up as an example of sterling character.

Barack Obama projected the aura of a demigod but beneath that he had a mean side. He was a bad winner and a worse loser (if he won in a basketball he teased the loser the rest of the day and if he lost then he pouted). He loved straw man arguments and allowed his staff to attribute political differences to racism. Plus there was the weaponizing of the Justice Department and the IRS plus innumerable other scandals that were under-reported.

Anyway, the argument that Trump is lacking in character is pretty specious.