Immigration Issues

Immigration is an international topic.

A couple of years ago France held an election to ratify the EU constitution. It failed, mainly because of worries about "Polish plumbers" and other eastern Europeans moving in and taking jobs from higher-paid native French.

The United Kingdom takes in around 220,000 immigrants. Recently Prime Minister Gordon Brown met with a supporter during a campaign trip. Part way through she started talking about immigrants taking British jobs and how people couldn't talk about them. Brown muttered something about the number of emigrants balancing the immigrants and left. Forgetting that he was wearing an open mic, he told his staff that the woman was a bigot. This was repeated by reporters and Brown has been trying to control the damage ever since.

In Arizona, a law was passed trying to slow the influx of illegal immigrants. The left insists on seeing this in the harshest possible terms. Bob Cesca of the Huffington Post insists that this will bring back slavery. Desmond Tutu sees dark skinned people being arrested in the middle of the night for not keeping their papers with them in bed.

All of this reduces a complex issue into stereotypes. Yes, an influx of foreign workers can reduce demand and pay. During the boom years a few years ago, this was a good thing. Five percent unemployment is considered "full employment" meaning that there are jobs for everyone who wants one but some people have trouble locating the right job. Our employment rate was closer to three percent for years. That means jobs are not being filled. Things were not quite so bright in Europe but they were still pretty good.

Those days are gone and it makes sense to stop adding to the number of people looking for scarce jobs - especially to the unemployed.

In America, politicians (especially Democrats) have been avoiding this issue. The country is sharply divided. There is no middle ground. President Bush was attacked from both sides when he proposed a guest worker program.

Keep in mind that Arizona is concerned about illegal immigrants. Nearly one out of every fifteen people in Arizona is there illegally. This has a lot of ramifications besides "press 2 for Spanish". If Bob Cesca looked further into the issue he would find that thousands of illegal immigrants are being held in slavery in Arizona, right now.

Currently our Mexican border policy is the equivalent of "Don't ask. Don't tell." We make it difficult to enter the US but if you are willing to walk across desert, climb walls, and risk death from heat and human predators then you can stay.

After being burned under Bush, Republicans are reluctant to take up the issue again. The Democrats have actively avoided it, hinting to Hispanic voters that they support amnesty but failing to deliver.

An amnesty program was tried under President Reagan. It was supposed to be accompanied by stronger border enforcement. This part didn't happen and the immigration fight under Bush showed that there is strong resistance to closing the border. In the meantime, the possibility of another amnesty draws more illegals and insults legal immigrants.

President Obama made it clear that he does not intend to address immigration this year and he will not give any hints about what policies he supports. His administration has stepped up workplace enforcement but that misses the labor black market and drives illegals further underground. It also makes them easier prey for criminals - both domestic and imported.

Possibly the end result of all of this is that the individual countries in Europe and North America will become as porous as the individual states in the US with people free to travel between them at any time. This is opposed by a majority in most countries. Attitudes may change over the next several decades but in the meantime politicians need to be more responsive to their populations.